Skip to Search Skip to Live Player Skip to Content Skip to Footer
98.7 The Shark | Tampa Bay's Classic Rock How Green Day's 'Good Riddance' Almost Became a Bon Jovi-Style Ballad
  • Home
  • Latest Stories
        • News

          • Music
          • Entertainment
          • Lifestyle
          • Trending In Tampa Bay
        • Trending

  • On Air
        • Shows

          • Dave and Chuck The Freak
          • Meredith
          • Jeff Zito
        • Latest Dave & Chuck The Freak

  • Listen + Watch
        • Listen + Watch

          • Podcasts
          • Events
        • Dave & Chuck On Demand

        • More Podcasts

        • Galleries

        • Latest Peep Shows

  • Contests
  • Events
  • Shop
  • More
        • Connect

          • Contact Us
          • Download The ALL-NEW 98.7 The Shark App
          • Join The 98.7 Shark Tank
          • Ways To Listen
          • Advertise
          • Careers
        • The Shark Extras

          • Concerts
          • Contest Winner FAQ
          • Update Your Shark Tank E-mail Preferences
          • The Shark Storm Center
          • Tampa Bay Traffic
          • Beasley Best Community of Caring
        • Join The 98.7 Shark Tank

        • Advertise With The Shark

Rock News

  • Home
  • About
  • Articles

Rock News

Rock News

  • Home
  • About
  • Articles

How Green Day’s ‘Good Riddance’ Almost Became a Bon Jovi-Style Ballad

Author Erica Banas // Rock Music Reporter
October 18th, 2022 11:11 AM

Green Day has many outstanding songs in its catalog, but few are as transcendent as “Good Riddance (Time of Your Life).” Believe it or not, the acoustic ballad almost sounded way different.

In a retrospective piece from The Ringer, the string portion of the ballad took some time to figure out. The Ringer cited a quote from Billie Joe Armstrong in an interview with Kerrang! saying, “At first [we had] a whole orchestra in there, and they’d all come in like, ‘SHUNG!’ In the studio we played it as a big, Bon Jovi–style ballad. Now that was funny.”

Of course, the band eventually landed on a more minimalist approach utilizing a quartet for the string portion of “Good Riddance (Time of Your Life).” The song, itself, went on to be certified five-times platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA.)

Green Day: Top 40 Songs Ranked

  • 40. “Brutal Love” from ‘TRE’ (2012)

    Share

    It’s so close to “Bring It On Home To Me” that Green Day share a writing credit with the late Sam Cooke. Hey, if you’re going to “borrow,” borrow from the best. It’s one of the best songs from the ‘UNO’/’DOS’/’TRE’ era, which would have benefitted from some editing. The highlights would have made a solid album.

  • 39. “East Jesus Nowhere” from ‘21st Century Breakdown’ (2009)

    Share

    The title came from a line in the 2007 film ‘Juno’ (when Juno’s step-mom asks her, “Why would you drive all the way to East Jesus Nowhere?”) and inspired by Bill Maher’s 2008 anti-religion documentary ‘Religulous.’

  • 38. Green Day and the Cast of ‘American Idiot’ – “21 Guns” (2010)

    Share

    The idea of a Broadway musical based on Green Day’s songs was a bit ridiculous, but the Green Day of the 2000s was nothing if not ambitious. And some of the parts of the show really worked, including this song. Even better was when the cast of the show and Green Day recorded a new version together.

  • 37. “Troubled Times” from ‘Revolution Radio’ (2016)

    Share

    One of the highlights of the underrated ‘Revolution Radio’ album, the song marked something of a return to politically-charged songs.

  • 36. The Network – “Roshambo” from ‘Money Money 2020’ (2004)

    Share

    Who were the Network? Their lineup included singer/guitarist Fink, singer/bassist Van Gough and a drummer known only as The Snoo, and they suspiciously talked an awful lot of smack about Green Day. The band also -- allegedly -- included members of Devo (you can hear them on another song, “Hungry Hungry Models”).

  • 35. “See The Light” from ‘21st Century Breakdown’ (2009)

    Share

    It’s nearly as great of an album closer as “Whatsername” from ‘American Idiot,” and is another underrated Green Day song.

  • 34. “Kill The DJ” from ‘UNO’ (2012)

    Share

    First off: we do not endorse the message in this song’s title! The Clash was always a big influence on Green Day, but it tended to be the band’s ‘70s output. Here, Green Day seems under the influence of the Clash’s sprawling 1980 triple album, ‘Sandinista!’ And like ‘Sandinista!,’ the ‘UNO’/’DOS’/’TRE’ trilogy would have benefitted from some editing.

  • 33. “Father Of All…” from ‘Father Of All…’ (2020)

    Share

    How many Rock and Roll Hall of Fame bands still make records where they are experimenting? How many Rock and Roll Hall of Fame bands still make albums where they sound like they have something to prove? This first taste of the new album shows that the band still think they have something to prove.

  • 32. “Who Wrote Holden Caulfield?” from ‘Kerplunk!’ (1992)

    Share

    A gem from the band’s Lookout Records era, this is a tribute to the main character in J.D. Salinger’s ‘The Catcher In The Rye.’

  • 31. “Working Class Hero” from ‘Instant Karma: The Amnesty International Campaign to Save Darfur’ (2007)

    Share

    One of John Lennon’s most lyrically heavy songs, by 2007, Green Day had earned the respect and gravitas to be able to do the song justice.

  • 30. “Brain Stew”/”Jaded” from ‘Insomniac’ (1995)

    Share

    Billie Joe, Mike and Tre seem to be having a blast with a huge hard rock riff for “Brain Stew,” before returning to punk form for “Jaded.” It’s the perfect combonation for the arenas that they were now headlining.

  • 29. “2000 Light Years Away” from ‘Kerplunk!’ (1992)

    Share

    One of the best songs from their Lookout Records era, it shows Billie Joe Armstrong’s romantic streak: “I sit alone in my bedroom/Staring at the walls/I've been up all damn night long/My pulse is speeding/My love is yearning.”

  • 28. “King For A Day” from ‘Nimrod’ (1997)

    Share

    A rocking acoustic shuffle with a horn section, this song kind of fit in with the ska music that was dominating the airwaves. Billie Joe Armstrong told Billboard, “It would be funny for a bunch of macho fraternity guys to be singing along and, little do they know, the song's about being in drag."

  • 27. “Horseshoes And Handgrenades” from ‘21st Century Breakdown’ (2009)

    Share

    Sounding like an outtake from Green Day’s garage rock side-project the Foxboro Hot Tubs (more on that later), Billie Joe Armstrong introduces the song by roaring, “I’m not f---ing around!” And he wasn’t. This is another one that should have been a hit.

  • 26. U2 + Green Day – “The Saints Are Coming” (2006)

    Share

    One of the few covers on this list, this song from 1979 was originally by the Scottish punk rock band the Skids (who probably would not have imagined that a quarter-century later, two of the biggest bands would cover the song and perform it at an NFL game; they performed at the first post-Katrina Saints game at the Super Bowl).

  • 25. “Boulevard Of Broken Dreams” from ‘American Idiot’ (2004)

    Share

    Noel Gallagher of Oasis was a bit annoyed about this song, believing that Green Day ripped off “Wonderwall.” “They should have the decency to wait until I am dead [before stealing my songs]” he complained. “I, at least, pay the people I steal from that courtesy.” He should have taken the compliment and moved on.

  • 24. “Nice Guys Finish Last” from ‘Nimrod’ (1997)

    Share

    The song is great, and so is the video, which poked fun at football. Ironically, years later in 2006, Green Day would perform at the New Orleans Superdome with U2 before a Saints/Falcons game.

  • 23. “J.A.R. (Jason Andrew Relva)” from the ‘Angus’ soundtrack (1995)

    Share

    Somehow this song didn’t make it to ‘Dookie,’ but that didn’t matter. Green Day were so hot at the time and this song was so great it went to number one on Billboard’s Modern Rock charts. And it deserved to stand on its own from the ‘Dookie’ songs anyway - it was a tribute to Mike Dirnt’s friend Jason Andrew Relva, who died in 1992 from injuries suffered in a car accident.

  • 22. “Coming Clean” from ‘Dookie’ (1994)

    Share

    One of the first rock songs to address an LGBT person’s coming out, the lyrics “Secrets collecting dust but never forget/Skeletons come to life in my closet/I found out what it takes to be a man/Now mom and dad will never understand/What's happening to me” were revolutionary.

  • 21. “Warning” from ‘Warning’ (2000)

    Share

    We always knew that Green Day were big Kinks fans, but it didn’t usually get this obvious. Listen to this song and “Picture Book” back to back. That’s not a knock; this song was an amazing kickoff to their 2000 album, and it showed that they could be just as badass strumming acoustic guitars as they were bashing electric ones.

  • 20. “Pulling Teeth” from ‘Dookie’ (1994)

    Share

    We’ll hand the mic -- or the keyboard -- to Corey Taylor here. Yes, Corey Taylor of Slipknot. On his solo acoustic tour, he noted that he’s such a big Green Day fan that if *you* aren’t a fan, you can’t be friends with him. And this is his favorite song from ‘Dookie.’ If you haven’t listened to this jam in a while, give it a spin and then explain to us how it wasn’t a huge hit.

  • 19. “Armatage Shanks” from ‘Insomniac’ (1995)

    Share

    The leadoff track on “Insomniac.’ It showed fans that, despite selling millions of ‘Dookies,’ the band hadn’t let success get to their head.

  • 18. “Whatsername” from ‘American Idiot’ (2004)

    Share

    Most of Green Day’s best songs have ended up on the radio, but somehow this one didn’t. Was Green Day thinking of bringing ‘American Idiot’ to Broadway even in 2004? If you saw the stage production, you know that this song was the perfect high-energy ending to the show. But Green Day’s own version is the definitive version.

  • 17. “When I Come Around” from ‘Dookie’ (1994)

    Share

    Green Day strayed from the punk rock formula often over the years, but this is one of the first examples of it; “When I Come Around” was a perfect bit of pop-rock, and was irresistible even to those who don’t care about punk rock.

  • 16. “Hitchin’ A Ride” from ‘Nimrod’ (1997)

    Share

    One of the highlights of their concerts, the song’s subject matter -- alcohol dependency -- is dark. “Troubled times/You know I cannot lie/I'm off the wagon and I'm hitchin' a ride.”

  • 15. “She” from ‘Dookie” (1994)

    Share

    “Scream at me until my ears bleed/I'm taking heed just for you” was a line that Billie Joe Armstrong wrote for a girlfriend, and it showed a sensitivity that made him stand out from his peers. So did feminist lines like “She's figured out/All her doubts were someone else's point of view/Waking up this time to smash the silence with the brick of self-control.”

  • 14. “Geek Stink Breath” from “Insomniac’ (1995)

    Share

    The first single from the follow-up to ‘Dookie’ showed that the band weren’t changing direction too much (at least, not yet).

  • 13. “Welcome To Paradise” from ‘Dookie’ (1994)

    Share

    They recorded an earlier version of the song for 1992’s ‘Kerplunk!,’ but the ‘Dookie’ version is better. The song, about moving out of your parents’ home… something ‘Dookie’ certainly enabled all the guys in the band to do.

  • 12. Foxboro Hot Tubs – “Stop Drop and Roll” from ‘Stop Drop and Roll!!!” (2008)

    Share

    If you’re not familiar with Foxboro Hot Tubs, stop what you’re doing and get a copy of their album, it’s some of the best, and most fun, garage rock that you’ll ever hear. After ‘American Idiot,’ Billie Joe Armstrong, Mike Dirnt and Tre Cool decided to have some fun, and they formed a new band. Their 12-song album (their only one so far) lasts just 30 minutes, and all of those minutes are perfection.

  • 11. “Wake Me Up When September Ends” from ‘American Idiot’ (2004)

    Share

    When they started out in punk rock clubs, a full-on power ballad like this might not have gone over too well. By 2004, punk rock’s stringent rules weren’t as important, thankfully.

  • 10. “Know Your Enemy” from ‘21st Century Breakdown” (2009)

    Share

    By the 2000s, few current rock bands were addressing politics, but “Know Your Enemy” seemed like the perfect blend of Rage Against The Machine and the Ramones, two bands who were sadly long gone by then.

  • 9. “16” from ‘1,039/Smooth’(1990)

    Share

    In which Billie Joe Armstrong perfectly captures the angst of a teenager who thinks too much. “Every night I dream the same dream,” he yelped. “Of getting older and older all the time.” The song boasts one of Mike Dirnt’s funkiest basslines.

  • 8. “Minority” from ‘Warning’ (2000)

    Share

    By 2000, MTV’s accursed ‘TRL’ was steering pop culture from alternative rock to nu metal, boy bands and Britney. Green Day wanted no part of it, and they let us know on this acoustic rocker: “Stepped out of the line/Like a sheep runs from the herd/Marching out of time/To my own beat now,” indeed.

  • 7. “21st Century Breakdown” from ‘21st Century Breakdown’ (2009)

    Share

    ‘American Idiot’ (and ‘Warning’ before that) showed Green Day’s fans that they were stretching out musically; still, it was surprising to hear the piano intro that introduces this song. But very quickly, the title track of their 2009 opus moves into the operatic punk rock road that they started traveling on with ‘American Idiot.’ At this point, they were equally influenced by the Ramones *and* Queen.

  • 6. “Holiday” from ‘American Idiot’ (2004)

    Share

    ‘American Idiot’ was musically and thematically more ambitious than anything than Green Day had attempted up to this point, but “Holiday” showed that they could still knock out great, simple punk rock jams.

  • 5. “Walking Contradiction” from ‘Insomniac’ (1995)

    Share

    What do you do when you come from the punk rock underground and you suddenly realize that you’re a millionaire? That’s something that Billie Joe Armstrong seemed to struggle with early on, and you can hear him working it out here.

  • 4. “Good Riddance (Time Of Your Life)” from ‘Nimrod’ (1997)

    Share

    Would a goofy bunch of guys like Green Day ever be able to grow up? This acoustic ballad -- which was really a Billie Joe Armstrong solo song -- showed that the band’s singer/songwriter had more range than he’d been given credit for. This was a Green Day song that you could impress your parents with.

  • 3. “Basket Case” from ‘Dookie’ (1994)

    Share

    The second of three #1 modern rock radio singles from ‘Dookie,’ (the first was “Longview,” the third was “When I Come Around”), it was a fun song about going crazy.

  • 2. “Longview” from ‘Dookie’ (1994)

    Share

    Green Day had been around for five years by the time they *cough* dropped ‘Dookie,’ but this is the song and video that brought them into the homes and hearts of America. Like their peers from the north in Seattle, Green Day had their share of angst. But unlike those guys, they actually had some fun with it.

  • 1. “American Idiot” from ‘American Idiot’ (2004)

    Share

    This song, and the album that it came from, are probably why Green Day became one of the first bands of their generation to be inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Like a lot of their ‘90s peers, their cultural cache was slipping by 2000s. “American Idiot,” the leadoff track and first single from the album of the same name, showed an older, angrier and more ambitious Green Day, and the album was so strong, it catapulted them to the pop charts and stadium headlining status.

Erica Banas is a rock/classic rock news blogger who's well-versed in etiquette and extraordinarily nice. #TransRightsAreHumanRights
98.7 The Shark | Tampa Bay's Classic Rock

Sign me up for the 98.7 The Shark email newsletter!

Join the Shark Tank for latest news on your favorite classic rock artists. As well as exclusive contests, concert pre-sale codes, and what's going on in Tampa Bay.

*
*
By clicking "Subscribe" I agree to the website's terms of Service and Privacy Policy. I understand I can unsubscribe at any time.
Author Erica Banas // Rock Music Reporter
Category:
  • 98.7 The Shark
  • Music
  • Rock News
Tags:
Bon Jovi,Green Day

More 98.7 The Shark

Billboard Hints Something New Is Coming For The Bolts

Why Andrei Vasilevskiy Was Trying Not To Laugh During His Post Game Interview

Dog Owner Shares Story of Loss From Mystery Virus Going Around In the Tampa Area

‘Christmas Story’ Bully was Also in Classic Van Halen Music Video

A Look at ‘The Worst’ Holiday Candies

2 Pinellas Cities Rank Top Spots For Fastest-Growing Home Prices

Geddy Lee Releases Archived Demo About Neil Peart’s Family Tragedy

Tampa Shines as One of the Top Cities for Singles in America

1000+ Pound Gingerbread House On Display In Clearwater

Florida Takes 2 Top Spots as the ‘Most Fun’ Cities in America

Breast Milk Heals

LeBron James Has Changed His Number 4 Times

5 Scratch-Offs With The Best Odds At Winning Top Prizes

Taylor Swift Named Time’s Person Of The Year 2023

Norman Lear, Legendary TV Sitcom Creator, Dies at 101

Grilled Ice Cubes are the Latest Specialty Street Food in China?

Florida Man Tries To Steal Waffle House Tattoo

What Makes The Perfect Butt According To Science

Judge Sentences Woman To Working In Fast Food

Florida State NFL Draft Prospects: Where They Might Land

Paul McCartney Pays Tribute to Late Wings Bandmate Denny Laine

Denny Laine Dies at 79

Nicolas Cage Wants to Retire From Film, Move to TV

Tampa: Comedian Nate Bargatze Is Coming Here Is What You Need To Know

John Lennon: ‘Happy XMas (War Is Over)’ Inspires Animated Film

Need More Man Juice?

Antonio Brown Makes Shocking Claim About The Buccaneers

Rock Artists Make Up One-Third of 2023 ‘Billboard’ Top Tours List

Oxford’s 2023 Word Of The Year Might Need An Explanation

Pop Up Mini Golf At Armature Works This Weekend

Guy Finds Poop In His Delivery Order

Woman Uses Toothbrush To Stop From Choking Before It Backfires

New Supplement Claims To Give Guys More Semen

Florida Among Top States in Puppy Scam Money Losses

Lightning Players To Appear Tomorrow in Tampa

Are Restaurants Secretly Using Dating Apps to Attract Customers?

Julia Roberts Breaks Her Silence on Ex Matthew Perry

Caught Cheating

Florida: Here Is Why Florida State Did Not Make The Playoff

Geddy Lee, Alex Lifeson Haven’t Ruled Out Touring as Rush

FDA Agrees On A Drug’s Potential to Extend Lifespan In Large Dogs

Florida State Left Out of College Playoffs Despite Being ACC Champs

Two New Cruise Ships Set Sail From Florida Ports

Police Officer Removes Bat From Home With Unique Method

Mugshot of the Day: What Did Someone Do To Get Arrested At Rib City In Southwest Florida?

Delivery Driver Gets Held Hostage After Delivering Cold Kabab

Love Triangle Takes Deadly Turn For The Worst

Gene Simmons Dealt with Kidney Stone During Final KISS Show

Load More
Beasley Media Group
Download our station app

Download the app to LISTEN LIVE wherever you are and connect with us like never before!

About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • DMCA
  • Advertiser’s Terms and Conditions
  • FCC Public File
  • FCC Applications
  • General Contest Rules
  • Additional Contest Rules
  • EEO
Connect
  • Contact Us
  • Download The ALL-NEW 98.7 The Shark App
  • Join The 98.7 Shark Tank
  • Update Your Shark Tank E-mail Preferences
  • The 98.7 The Shark Storm Center
  • Use Alexa To Listen To The Shark
  • Beasley Best Community of Caring
  • Careers
  • Learn How to Advertise in Tampa Bay
  • Facebook
  • Twitter